# Make the KPI green. Reality is optional.

Date: 2026-11-17

Bad Management 101

The dashboard is green. Kindly ignore the smoke.

<!--more-->

I am not against goals, and I am not against being held to a number. Specific, challenging goals can lift performance. That finding has been repeated for decades, and Lisa Ordóñez, Maurice Schweitzer, Adam Galinsky, and Max Bazerman say so before they object to anything. Their 2009 paper, “Goals Gone Wild,” is a review and an argument. It is not one experiment proving that targets are a mistake.

Their warning is about dose. A narrow goal pulls attention off whatever the goal forgets to mention. A very hard goal can tilt people toward risk, and toward cheating when they are close and nobody is watching the method. A short clock can finish this quarter by spending the next one. When both a quantity goal and a quality goal were difficult, people in one study let quality slip. Quantity was easier to prove.

Their review, drawing on earlier studies, adds two quieter failures. People can treat a cleared goal as a ceiling and ease off. On a complex job, a hard performance target can also get in the way of learning, because people repeat the method that protects the number instead of trying a better one. The useful discipline is to ask what the goal might distort before it is signed, not after the side effect has a name.

Take a service target defined as tickets closed. The cell goes green. The customers are still stuck, because reopening a ticket would spoil the week. Nobody rebelled. They followed the instruction inside the metric. Make the count, and let the rest wait.

Before I approve a target, I want the neglected list on the same page. What will people drop, delay, or quietly redefine to move this number? If the honest answer is “nothing,” the goal is not finished. A board that asks only whether we hit it has not started the oversight.

Measurement stays. Accountability stays. A green cell that was bought by a worse outcome we declined to count is not a result I will treat as finished.

If the only thing on fire is the metric, look at the building.

I have a one-hour course on how to improve your management skills [Contact me](https://goldmanmalka.com/about).

Lisa D. Ordóñez, Maurice E. Schweitzer, Adam D. Galinsky, and Max H. Bazerman (2009). “Goals Gone Wild: The Systematic Side Effects of Over-Prescribing Goal Setting.” Harvard Business School Working Paper 09-083. https://www.hbs.edu/ris/Publication%20Files/09-083.pdf
