Your best salesperson deserves a team to mismanage.

·

Bad Management 101

We know how to honour excellent work. We take the person off that work and hand them a different job.

Alan Benson, Danielle Li, and Kelly Shue looked for this pattern in sales. In their February 2018 working paper, they used records on 53,035 sales workers at 214 US firms, from 2005 to 2011. Of those workers, 1,531 were promoted into management. Higher sales made promotion more likely. After the promotion, higher prior sales predicted lower sales from each new manager’s subordinates. Doubling pre-promotion sales corresponded to a 7.5 percent decline in each subordinate’s sales. Collaboration experience pointed the other way. It predicted better managerial results, and firms did not consistently promote on it.

Read the average. This is a pattern among salespeople who were promoted in that dataset. It is not a finding that every top performer becomes a poor manager. Some stars will be the right managers. Current sales are still a weak guide to the next job, and these firms leaned on them anyway. The quality measure is the manager’s estimated effect on subordinate sales, not a personality score. The data also cannot show promotion offers that people turned down.

The authors do not treat the pattern as proof that firms are simply mistaken. Promoting on a number people can see may keep effort up, and it can look fairer than a private judgement. They estimate that choosing only for managerial quality would have produced managers 30 percent higher on a measure of their effect on subordinate sales. Firms already put less weight on sales when the management job carried more responsibility, and when pay for selling was already strong. The incentive is real. So is the cost of skipping the test for the next role.

If I own succession, I split the reward from the job. Pay for great selling. Promote for the ability to manage. Keep a path that a brilliant individual contributor can walk without being handed a team. A board should ask which of those we do, and which we only put on a slide.

The best closer in the company is allowed to remain the best closer.

I have a one-hour course on how to improve your management skills Contact me.

Alan Benson, Danielle Li, and Kelly Shue (February 2018). “Promotions and the Peter Principle.” NBER Working Paper No. 24343. https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w24343/w24343.pdf