Protect the rainmaker. Replace everyone else.

·

Bad Management 101

One person hits the number. The people around that person start looking for the exit. We treat that as the cost of getting the result.

Donald Sull, Charles Sull, and Ben Zweig asked what predicted attrition at large, mainly for-profit US companies from April to September 2021. They compared each company with others in its industry, and they used employee reviews to see which topics best predicted the gap. Talk about compensation ranked 16th among the topics they tested. A toxic culture was first. In their model it carried 10.4 times the predictive importance of compensation.

Keep the label on that figure. It is not one person’s odds of quitting. It is not a multiplier for every firm and every year. It does not prove that culture causes the exit. It is the topic’s weight, relative to compensation, in predicting industry-adjusted attrition in that sample and those six months. In their account, the toxic-culture signal included disrespect, unethical behaviour, and a failure to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion.

Two limits belong next to the headline. The reviews are not a census of every employee, and the attrition count includes people who quit, retired, or were laid off. The 10.4 figure comes from a prediction model. It says which topic helped predict the gap. It does not say what would happen if the culture changed and everything else stayed still.

Pay still matters. The same research ranks compensation lower. Lower is not zero. I would not set wages from this paper, and I would not wave pay away with it.

The study never examined a protected rainmaker. That character is an illustration, not a result. The habit I mean is narrower than the dataset and older than 2021: we keep the result and excuse the conduct that produced it. Contempt, corner-cutting, or humiliation does not become leadership because the quarter landed.

Executives decide what they will correct this week. Boards decide what they are willing to keep seeing. Ask how the number was made, and who is paying for the method. A target can outlast the conduct we excused. The people asked to absorb that conduct often will not.

I have a one-hour course on how to improve your management skills Contact me.

Donald Sull, Charles Sull, and Ben Zweig (11 January 2022). “Toxic Culture Is Driving the Great Resignation.” MIT Sloan Management Review. https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/toxic-culture-is-driving-the-great-resignation/