Bad Management 101
A quiet board pack looks like health. Often it is just good manners, in a room where bad news has a price.
Amy Edmondson studied this in 1999, in 51 work teams inside one manufacturing company. She used the term psychological safety for a shared belief: people can admit a mistake, ask for help, or challenge a plan without being embarrassed, rejected, or punished. Teams with more of that belief also reported more learning behaviour. They asked for feedback, talked about errors, and went looking for information. That behaviour lined up with better performance, as rated by people outside the team who received the work.
Keep the claim the size of the evidence. One company. A snapshot. The design cannot show that safety causes results. Edmondson also treats the findings on leaders as tentative, because those measures came from the same survey as the beliefs. What the study supports is narrower, and still useful. The belief that speaking up is safe, and the act of speaking up, travel together.
Her interviews show the same split in plain language. In one team, people avoided questioning the assignment because they feared a penalty from management. In another, members treated a pointed-out mistake as information, because they believed the aim was a better product. That is description, not a recipe. The rule I will use is still plain. The first minute after an awkward fact should be uneventful. Hear it. Ask what else is true. Decide what we will do.
Picture a Monday pipeline review. The work is late. The person who says so is asked why they are being negative. Next month the slide says on track. The delay is unchanged. Only the wording has been improved.
If I run the organisation, that wording is feedback. People watch what happens to the person who brings the awkward fact. A flinch, a public grilling, a joke at their expense, and the next report gets shorter before anyone writes it. The problem stays in the building. It stops reaching the people who can still act on it cheaply.
A board that enjoys a spotless pack should ask a dull question. Are we seeing fewer problems, or receiving fewer reports?
Silence is a comfortable number. It is a poor one.
I have a one-hour course on how to improve your management skills Contact me.
Amy Edmondson (1999). “Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams.” Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383. https://web.mit.edu/curhan/www/docs/Articles/15341_Readings/Group_Performance/Edmondson%20Psychological%20safety.pdf
