Bad Management 101
These questions will not diagnose a career. They ask whether four habits are running where we can still see them.
Bad news. In 1999 Amy Edmondson studied 51 work teams in one manufacturing company. Teams whose members believed they could admit a mistake, ask for help, or challenge a plan, without being embarrassed or punished, also reported more learning. That behaviour was associated with better performance, rated by people who received the work. One company, and not a proof of cause. A quiet room is not the same thing as a healthy one.
Targets. Lisa Ordóñez, Maurice Schweitzer, Adam Galinsky, and Max Bazerman did not find that goals are foolish. Their 2009 review says specific, challenging goals can raise performance, and that those same goals can narrow attention, invite cheating, and push risk into whatever the target forgot. A green KPI is one number. It is not the operation.
Promotion. Alan Benson, Danielle Li, and Kelly Shue studied sales workers at 214 US firms from 2005 to 2011, in a February 2018 working paper. Stronger sales made promotion more likely. After promotion, stronger prior sales predicted weaker subordinate sales. Doubling pre-promotion sales corresponded to a 7.5 percent decline in each subordinate’s sales. That is an average in this sales data, not a fate for every star. Promoting on current results can protect effort and a sense of fairness, and it can cost managerial fit. Pay for the selling. Test for the managing. Keep a credible path for excellent people who should not have a team.
The exception. Donald Sull, Charles Sull, and Ben Zweig found that, from April to September 2021, a toxic culture had 10.4 times the predictive importance of compensation for industry-adjusted attrition at large, mainly for-profit US companies. That is not one person’s chance of leaving, and it is not proof of cause. Pay still matters. They did not study rainmakers. Excusing damaging behaviour because the number landed is an illustration, not their finding. The result counts. The way it was made counts with it.
This is a reflection tool. It is not a validated test. There is no cutoff, no scientific score, and no research result that turns these answers into a diagnosis.
Answer yes or no. Yes is the warning sign.
On bad news and disagreement
- When someone brings me a problem I dislike, do they leave the conversation more cautious than when they entered?
- In the last serious review, did I treat disagreement as disloyalty, delay, or a personal failing?
On targets and damage
- Can I name a real harm, shortcut, or neglected duty that would still leave our main KPI looking successful?
- Have we celebrated a target without asking what people had to ignore or manipulate to hit it?
On promotion
- Have I promoted someone mainly for excellence in their current job, without a serious test of whether they can do the management job?
- Is a management title the only credible way for a top performer here to be rewarded?
On conduct we excuse
- Is there a high performer whose damaging behaviour I have explained away because of their results?
- Have I tolerated behaviour from a high performer that I would not accept from someone missing the target?
Yes marks a habit, not a kind of person. People learn what is safe to say, what a number may damage, who receives a team, and who is exempt.
Do not stop at this page, including when the answers feel comfortable. Self-assessment is the view from the chair that sets the tone. Ask, in confidence, the people who have to live with the behaviour. If they will not say, that silence belongs with question 1.
Boards do not run the week. They decide what is rewarded, what is tolerated, and what they are willing to see. Executives decide what the organisation practises between meetings. A leadership habit that survives both is no longer a personal style. It is the policy.
I have a one-hour course on how to improve your management skills Contact me.
Edmondson (1999), Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383. https://web.mit.edu/curhan/www/docs/Articles/15341_Readings/Group_Performance/Edmondson%20Psychological%20safety.pdf
Ordóñez, Schweitzer, Galinsky, and Bazerman (2009), Harvard Business School Working Paper 09-083. https://www.hbs.edu/ris/Publication%20Files/09-083.pdf
Benson, Li, and Shue (February 2018), NBER Working Paper 24343. https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w24343/w24343.pdf
Sull, Sull, and Zweig (11 January 2022), MIT Sloan Management Review. https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/toxic-culture-is-driving-the-great-resignation/
